Innovative Commercial Strategies Innovative Commercial Strategies CRE Advisory + AI Systems

Glossary · Commercial real estate

Bad-boy carve-outs

Exceptions in a non-recourse loan that make the borrower or guarantor personally liable for misconduct.

What it means

Bad-boy carve-outs are the exceptions to a non-recourse loan. The lender agrees to look only to the property for repayment, except where the borrower commits certain acts. Those acts are listed in a carve-out guaranty, usually signed by a principal with real net worth.

Why it matters on the South Shore

Local banks here mostly lend with full personal guaranties, so carve-outs show up when a South Shore owner graduates to larger debt: an agency or CMBS loan on an apartment portfolio in Quincy, or a life company loan on a Route 3 retail center. Owners used to community bank paper sometimes read “non-recourse” and stop reading. The carve-out guaranty is where the personal exposure sits.

In practice

An owner closes a $6,000,000 non-recourse loan on a Weymouth retail center. Two years later a partner records a $400,000 second mortgage without lender consent. The loan documents treat that as a full-recourse event, so the guarantor is now personally exposed to the whole $6,000,000 balance, over a $400,000 decision. A consent request to the servicer first would have avoided it.

Straight answers

What triggers a bad-boy carve-out?
Typical triggers are fraud, misapplying rents or insurance proceeds, unpaid property taxes when cash was available, waste, a prohibited transfer of the property, and a voluntary bankruptcy filing. The exact list is negotiated loan by loan, so the only reliable answer is the one written in your guaranty.
Can a carve-out make the whole loan recourse?
Yes. Most guaranties have two tiers. Some acts make the guarantor liable only for the lender's actual loss. Others, often a bankruptcy filing or an unapproved sale or second mortgage, convert the entire loan balance to full recourse. Have your attorney mark which events fall in which tier.

Related terms

← All 537 terms · Talk to a licensed advisor about your deal →

Hearing this term in a deal right now?

Call before you sign. A straight read on the clause, the number, or the pitch, usually in one conversation.