Glossary · Commercial real estate
Good-guy guaranty
A limited personal guaranty that ends when the tenant vacates, surrenders the space, and is current on rent.
What it means
A good-guy guaranty is a personal guaranty with an exit. The principal of a tenant business guarantees the lease personally, but the guaranty terminates if the tenant gives the required notice, vacates, surrenders the premises in the condition the lease requires, and is current on all rent and charges through the surrender date. If the tenant leaves on those terms, the “good guy” is released and the landlord’s only recourse for future rent is against the tenant entity. If the tenant stays in default or leaves owing money, the guaranty stays in force.
Why it matters on the South Shore
Most South Shore commercial tenants are small businesses, and most landlords want a personal guaranty from the owner. A full guaranty on a five-year lease can mean personal exposure of several hundred thousand dollars. The good-guy structure gives the landlord what it most needs, a tenant who will not squat and will leave the space clean, while giving the owner a way out if the business fails. ICS recommends it as the middle ground for tenant clients in Brockton and Weymouth who would otherwise refuse to guarantee at all.
In practice
A restaurant owner signs a five-year lease on a 2,800 square foot space in Rockland at $30 per square foot, $84,000 a year, with a good-guy guaranty requiring 90 days notice. In month 20 the restaurant is failing. The owner gives notice, pays rent through month 23, cleans out the space, and returns the keys. The remaining 37 months of rent, about $259,000, are owed by the LLC alone, which has no assets. Under a full guaranty the landlord could have pursued the owner personally for that balance, less whatever it recovered by re-leasing.
Straight answers
- Is a good-guy guaranty common in Massachusetts?
- It is a New York concept, but South Shore landlords increasingly accept it when a small business cannot or will not give a full personal guaranty. The key is the drafting: a Massachusetts version must spell out exactly what the guarantor owes, the notice period, and what counts as a clean surrender. Have your attorney review it.
- What does the guarantor still owe under a good-guy guaranty?
- Everything that accrued up to the date the tenant hands back the keys with rent paid and the space in the required condition. That includes unpaid rent, late charges, and repair costs through surrender. What the guarantor escapes is the rent for the remaining term after surrender, which under a full guaranty could be years.
Related terms
-
Personal guaranty
The owner's personal promise to pay if the business entity defaults on the lease or loan.
-
Security deposit and letter of credit
The landlord's protection against tenant default: cash held, or a bank's standby commitment.
-
Surrender clause
The lease terms governing the condition a tenant must leave the space in when the lease ends.
-
Holdover
Staying in the space after the lease ends, usually at a penalty rent.
Where this term shows up
In a lease: Security deposit and letter of credit · Personal guaranty (Lease Clause Decoder)
In the Insights:
Terms that point here: Corporate guaranty
← All 537 terms · Talk to a licensed advisor about your deal →