Glossary · Intelligence & research
Redaction
Removing exempt information from a public record before release, with the exemption cited for each removal.
What it means
Redaction is the practice of blacking out or removing portions of a record that fall under a legal exemption while releasing the remainder. Under the Massachusetts Public Records Law, a records access officer must segregate exempt material from non-exempt material and cite the specific exemption for each redaction. Redactions in electronic files should be done in a way that actually removes the text, not simply covers it.
Why it matters in a dossier
Redactions are information too. A police log entry with a name removed still shows a date, a location, and a category of call. A town contract with pricing blacked out still shows the vendor, the term, and the signers. ICS reads what remains and appeals what seems over-withheld. It never attempts to recover redacted text by technical means from a file an agency released; if the agency made an error, the right move is to tell them.
In practice
A Plymouth department releases 140 pages of email about a sewer extension with 31 redactions, each citing the personal privacy exemption. Twelve of them cover a developer’s business email address, which is not personal information. An appeal to the Supervisor of Records takes 23 days and produces an unredacted release of those twelve. The developer’s correspondence with the board was the point of the request.
Straight answers
- What can a Massachusetts agency redact?
- Only information covered by a specific exemption in the Public Records Law, such as personal privacy details, certain investigatory materials, or records protected by another statute. The agency must release the rest of the document and must tell you which exemption supports each redaction. Blanket withholding of a whole file is rarely justified.
- What if a redaction seems excessive?
- Appeal to the Supervisor of Records within 90 days of the response. The appeal is free, is decided in writing, and often results in an order to release more. Describe what was withheld and why the cited exemption does not fit; the Supervisor's prior determinations are public and useful to quote.
Related terms
-
Massachusetts Public Records Law
The state law giving the public the right to request records held by government agencies and municipalities.
-
Public records request fees
What a Massachusetts agency may charge to search for, redact, and copy public records, and the limits on it.
-
Need-to-know handling
Sensitive findings go only to the people who must have them, in the form they need.
-
Metadata
Data about a file or record: who created it, when, with what, and how it changed.