Glossary · AI systems & marketing
Review gating
Asking only customers you already know are happy to leave a public review, which Google's policies prohibit.
What it means
Review gating is the practice of asking customers how they feel before asking for a review, then sending only satisfied customers to a public review site while routing unhappy ones to a private form. The goal is an inflated public rating. Google’s Business Profile policies prohibit it, and the FTC’s 2024 rule on fake and suppressed reviews makes it a federal compliance question as well.
Why it matters for a local business
Many review-request tools sold to small businesses still do this by default, and the owner may not know. A Weymouth dentist whose vendor “filters” reviews is exposed on two fronts: Google can remove reviews or act against the profile, and the FTC rule allows civil penalties for suppressing negative reviews. Proof Engine does not gate. It asks every customer, sends the same link to everyone, and uses the feedback question only to alert the owner that someone needs a call. An honest 4.6 is more durable and more convincing than a filtered 4.9.
In practice
A Brockton auto shop’s previous vendor had pushed 4- and 5-star responders to Google and 1- to 3-star responders to a private form. Its profile showed 4.9 stars on 70 reviews while the private forms held 40 complaints no one read. ICS replaced the flow with an ask-everyone sequence. The rating settled at 4.6 on 190 reviews within a year, the shop fixed the two issues the complaints repeated, and call volume from the profile rose anyway. If you suspect a current or past vendor has been gating on your behalf, talk to counsel.
Straight answers
- Is review gating illegal?
- It violates Google's review policies, which prohibit discouraging negative reviews or selectively soliciting positive ones, and businesses have had reviews removed over it. The FTC's 2024 rule on fake reviews and testimonials also covers suppressing negative reviews, with civil penalties possible. Talk to counsel about your specific practice.
- How do I ask for reviews the right way?
- Ask every customer, the same way, after every job, and give everyone the same public link. You may ask a feedback question first as long as the review invitation does not depend on the answer. Use the unhappy answers to fix problems and call the customer, not to hide them.
Related terms
-
Reputation management
The ongoing work of earning, monitoring, and responding to reviews and public mentions of your business.
-
Proof Engine
ICS's system that turns finished jobs into reviews, photos, and content automatically.
-
Net Promoter Score (NPS)
A loyalty metric from one question: how likely are you to recommend us, scored 0 to 10.
-
Review velocity
How many new reviews a business earns per month, which matters more than its total.
Where this term shows up
In the Insights:
Terms that point here: Review QR code