Glossary · Commercial real estate
Underwriting
The analysis a buyer or lender does to test a property's income, expenses, risks, and value before committing money.
What it means
Underwriting is the disciplined analysis of a property’s income, expenses, leases, physical condition, market position, and financing to decide whether to buy or lend, and at what price or loan amount. For a buyer it produces a stabilized NOI, a return on cost and on equity, and a maximum price. For a lender it produces a loan amount constrained by loan to value, debt service coverage, and debt yield. Good underwriting is a list of assumptions, each defended by a document or a comp.
Why it matters on the South Shore
Most South Shore commercial deals are small enough that nobody else will underwrite them for you. The seller’s broker supplies a one-page setup, the local bank orders an appraisal after you are under agreement, and the surprises come from the leases, the taxes, and the roof. ICS underwrites each South Shore acquisition for a client the way a lender will: tenant by tenant, with a reassessment at the purchase price, which in Brockton, Taunton, or Weymouth can add $20,000 or more to the tax line, and with the rollover schedule laid against market rent. The Buyer Brief packages that work for the client and the bank.
In practice
A seller lists a 15,000 square foot mixed-use building in Quincy at $3.9 million with a pro forma NOI of $290,000, a 7.4 percent cap rate. Buyer underwriting: actual rents are $18,000 lower, taxes rise $24,000 after reassessment, a 4 percent management fee costs $14,500, and reserves add $3,000. Adjusted NOI is $230,500. At the same 7.4 percent cap, the supported price is about $3.1 million, and a 70 percent loan at 7 percent on a 25-year schedule covers debt service at 1.25 times, right at the bank’s floor.
Straight answers
- What does a lender look at when underwriting a commercial property?
- The property's net operating income after its own adjustments for vacancy, management, and reserves; the debt service coverage ratio, usually 1.20 to 1.25 or better; the loan to value, typically 65 to 75 percent; debt yield; the tenants' credit and lease terms; the borrower's experience, liquidity, and net worth; and the appraisal and environmental reports. The loan is sized to the weakest of these.
- How is buyer underwriting different from the seller's pro forma?
- The seller's pro forma shows the best plausible case: full occupancy, market rents on vacant space, no management fee, last year's taxes. Buyer underwriting replaces each assumption with one you can defend: actual rents, scheduled rollover, re-leasing cost, a reassessment at the new price, reserves, and a management fee. The gap between the two is the negotiation.
Related terms
-
Pro forma
A projected operating statement showing what a property should earn going forward.
-
DSCR (debt service coverage ratio)
Net operating income divided by annual loan payments; lenders want cushion.
-
Cap rate (capitalization rate)
The yield a property produces if you paid cash: net operating income divided by price.
-
Debt yield
NOI divided by loan amount: a lender's sizing test that ignores interest rate and amortization.
← All 537 terms · Talk to a licensed advisor about your deal →