November 4, 2026 · Daniel Lawton
Ten questions to ask any marketing vendor before you sign, with our answers
A deck is a promise about the future. A contract is a promise about the past: what was agreed. The gap between them is where most agency relationships go wrong, and it closes fast if you ask ten plain questions before you sign. Here they are, with the answers we give, because a vendor who will not answer them in writing has already told you something.
1. What exactly goes live, and by what date?
Not “a new website.” A list: the pages, the quote tool, the tracking, the review requests, the profile work, with a date. Ours is published as the first 90 days, phase by phase for each system. JobSite goes live by day 21 of kickoff. Lead Engine’s response automation switches on in week one.
2. Who owns the website, the domain, the accounts, and the data?
You should, from day one, with the vendor as a manager who can be removed. If a vendor hosts your site on their account, owns your ad account, or keeps your leads in their CRM, you are renting your own business. Our answer is the You-Own-Everything guarantee: code, domain, accounts, data, yours, always.
3. How is the result measured, and against what?
A result is a number compared to a baseline that was written down before the work started. Ask what the baseline is, who measures it, and where you can see it. We measure the baseline at kickoff (response time, quote-to-booked, reviews per month), agree the 90-day target in writing, and report it monthly.
4. What happens if you miss, in dollars?
A guarantee without a consequence is a slogan. Ours: live in 21 days or a $1,000-per-week credit; under 60 seconds to first response, measured monthly, or the month is credited; 90 days to measurable improvement or we work at no monthly fee until there is. And one thing we will not guarantee, because nobody honestly can: revenue.
5. What does the first month cost me in time?
A good system runs without you; a good vendor tells you what they need and when. Ours is about five hours in the first month (a kickoff, two or three review calls, a launch walkthrough) and a thirty-minute review every month after. The kickoff checklist lists the access and material that start the clock.
6. What is in the monthly report?
Ask to see one. If it leads with impressions, keep asking. Ours leads with whether the month was good and why, measures the guarantee, shows leads by source and the pipeline from lead to booked, and ends with what we did and what we do next. There is a sample on the site with invented numbers, labeled as such.
7. How long is the contract, and how does it end?
Month to month after the build, with everything staying yours, is the honest default. Market Lock is the exception by design: a twelve-month term because exclusivity has to mean something, with first right to renew.
8. Who actually does the work?
Ask to meet them. At ICS the person on the call is the person who builds the system and reads your report. There is no account manager and no hand-off.
9. What does it cost, before the call?
A vendor who publishes prices can be qualified in thirty seconds and has nowhere to hide on the written quote. Ours are on the pricing page, and the Proposal Builder writes the proposal from them. The Payback Calculator shows when each system pays back on your numbers, at both ends of the range.
10. What would you tell me not to buy?
The best answer to this question is specific. Ours: if your volume does not support Market Lock, we will say so and scope down; if your response time is the whole problem, fix it with the free 90-Day Playbook first and call when the leads outgrow it.
Ask all ten. Write down the answers. Then sign the one that put them in writing before you asked.
Common questions
- What should I ask a marketing agency before signing a contract?
- What exactly goes live and by what date; who owns the website, domain, ad accounts, CRM, and data; how the promised result is measured and against what baseline; what happens if they miss, in dollars; what the first ninety days look like week by week; what they need from you and when; what the monthly report contains; how long the contract runs and how it ends; who actually does the work; and what it costs, published, before the call.
- Who should own the website and the data when working with an agency?
- You should, always: the domain in your registrar account, the site in a repository and hosting you can access, the ad accounts and Business Profile under your ownership with the agency as a manager, and the CRM in your name. If the relationship ends, everything should keep working without them. ICS writes this into every engagement as the You-Own-Everything guarantee.
- What does a good marketing guarantee look like?
- It names a behavior the vendor controls, a date or a number, and a consequence in dollars. 'Live in 21 days or a $1,000-per-week credit' is a guarantee. 'We are confident you will see results' is not. Revenue cannot be honestly guaranteed; the behavior of the system and measured improvement against your own baseline can.
- What happens in the first 90 days of an ICS engagement?
- It depends on the system, and it is published week by week: JobSite goes live by day 21; Lead Engine switches on sub-60-second response in week one and is fully live in four to six weeks; Market Lock locks the territory in writing on day zero and is fully live in six to eight weeks. Every phase lists what ICS does, what the client provides, and what they have at the end, with the written guarantees attached to the phases they cover.