Glossary · Intelligence & research
Analysis of competing hypotheses (ACH)
A structured method that tests every plausible explanation against the evidence instead of defending the first one.
What it means
Analysis of competing hypotheses is an analytic technique developed in the intelligence community to reduce confirmation bias. By evaluating evidence against a full set of hypotheses simultaneously and focusing on disconfirmation, it produces judgments that are more defensible and more honest about what the evidence cannot settle.
Why it matters on the South Shore
A pattern of LLC transfers on a South Shore property might mean estate planning, lender pressure, or something worse. ICS’s practice is to lay out all three, test each against the record, and tell the client which survives and how confidently, rather than lead with the most dramatic reading.
Straight answers
- How does ACH work?
- List every reasonable hypothesis, list the evidence, and mark whether each piece of evidence is consistent or inconsistent with each hypothesis. The hypothesis with the least inconsistent evidence survives, not the one with the most supporting evidence. It is designed to defeat the human habit of confirming what we already believe.
- When does ICS use ACH?
- Whenever a finding could be read more than one way: an unusual ownership structure, a pattern of filings, a gap in a public record. The sample dossier includes a worked ACH table so clients can see how a conclusion was reached and challenge it.
Related terms
-
Source grading (Admiralty code)
Rating each source's reliability (A to F) and each piece of information's credibility (1 to 6).
-
Confidence levels
Stating how sure the analyst is: high, moderate, or low, and why.
-
BLUF (bottom line up front)
Stating the conclusion first, then the evidence; the standard structure of an intelligence product.
Where this term shows up
Terms that point here: The Deep Dossier · Chronology (timeline analysis) · Disconfirming evidence · Key assumptions check · Red team review · Structured analytic techniques