Glossary · Intelligence & research
Source grading (Admiralty code)
Rating each source's reliability (A to F) and each piece of information's credibility (1 to 6).
What it means
Source grading assigns a two-part rating to every item of information: the historical reliability of its source and the independent credibility of the information itself. The Admiralty or NATO system, letters A through F and numbers 1 through 6, is the common standard, and it lets readers distinguish established fact from plausible report.
Why it matters on the South Shore
ICS applies the Admiralty system in every Deep Dossier and marks grades inline so a client can see at a glance which findings are rock and which are sand. The fictional sample on this site demonstrates it page by page.
Straight answers
- What do the letters and numbers in a source grade mean?
- The letter rates the source: A is completely reliable, F is reliability unknown. The number rates the specific information: 1 is confirmed by independent sources, 6 is truth cannot be judged. A Registry of Deeds record might be A1; an anonymous online claim might be F6. The grade travels with every finding.
- Why grade sources at all?
- Because not all facts are equal and a reader deserves to know which findings rest on a court record and which on a single news article. Grading is how an intelligence product is honest about its own uncertainty and how a decision-maker weighs it correctly.
Related terms
-
BLUF (bottom line up front)
Stating the conclusion first, then the evidence; the standard structure of an intelligence product.
-
Confidence levels
Stating how sure the analyst is: high, moderate, or low, and why.
-
Analysis of competing hypotheses (ACH)
A structured method that tests every plausible explanation against the evidence instead of defending the first one.
Where this term shows up
In the Insights:
Terms that point here: Chain of custody (for findings) · The Deep Dossier · OSINT (open-source intelligence) · Adverse media screening · Collection plan · Corroboration · Intelligence cycle · Primary vs. secondary source