Glossary · Intelligence & research
Primary vs. secondary source
The original record of a fact versus someone else's account of it, and why the dossier prefers the former.
What it means
A primary source is the original record created at the time of an event by a party to it: a deed, a filed complaint, a permit, a campaign finance report. A secondary source describes, summarizes, or interprets primary material: a news article, a commercial database summary, a book. Primary sources carry fewer layers of interpretation and error, so they are preferred for any fact a dossier will stand behind.
Why it matters in a dossier
Most of what circulates about a South Shore business or official is secondary and often wrong in the details: the wrong year, the wrong entity, a settlement described as a judgment. ICS treats secondary material as a map to primary records and cites only the primary record. When a primary record cannot be obtained, the finding is downgraded in confidence and labeled as resting on secondary sources. The client sees which is which.
In practice
A background article says a Quincy developer “lost a $3 million lawsuit” in 2021. The Norfolk Superior Court docket shows a case that settled for an undisclosed amount with no judgment entered, and a separate 2019 case in which the developer was the plaintiff and won. The dossier reports both from the dockets. The article was a useful lead and a poor source.
Straight answers
- What counts as a primary source in public-records research?
- The record itself: the recorded deed, the court docket and filed pleadings, the OCPF contribution report, the annual report on file with the Secretary of the Commonwealth, the board's own minutes. A news article describing any of those is secondary. So is a database that summarizes them, until you have checked the underlying document.
- Are secondary sources useless?
- No, they are leads. A newspaper story tells you a lawsuit exists and roughly when, which is what you need to find the docket. An aggregator tells you a person has lived in three towns, which tells you which Registries to search. The finding is cited to the primary record the lead pointed to.
Related terms
-
Source grading (Admiralty code)
Rating each source's reliability (A to F) and each piece of information's credibility (1 to 6).
-
Corroboration
Confirming a fact through a second independent public source before it is stated as a finding.
-
Source citation
Recording exactly where each fact came from so a reader can retrieve the same record and check it.
-
Adverse media screening
A structured search of news and public sources for negative coverage tied to a person or company.
Where this term shows up
Terms that point here: News archive · Findings of fact