Innovative Commercial Strategies Innovative Commercial Strategies CRE Advisory + AI Systems

Glossary · Intelligence & research

Primary vs. secondary source

The original record of a fact versus someone else's account of it, and why the dossier prefers the former.

What it means

A primary source is the original record created at the time of an event by a party to it: a deed, a filed complaint, a permit, a campaign finance report. A secondary source describes, summarizes, or interprets primary material: a news article, a commercial database summary, a book. Primary sources carry fewer layers of interpretation and error, so they are preferred for any fact a dossier will stand behind.

Why it matters in a dossier

Most of what circulates about a South Shore business or official is secondary and often wrong in the details: the wrong year, the wrong entity, a settlement described as a judgment. ICS treats secondary material as a map to primary records and cites only the primary record. When a primary record cannot be obtained, the finding is downgraded in confidence and labeled as resting on secondary sources. The client sees which is which.

In practice

A background article says a Quincy developer “lost a $3 million lawsuit” in 2021. The Norfolk Superior Court docket shows a case that settled for an undisclosed amount with no judgment entered, and a separate 2019 case in which the developer was the plaintiff and won. The dossier reports both from the dockets. The article was a useful lead and a poor source.

Straight answers

What counts as a primary source in public-records research?
The record itself: the recorded deed, the court docket and filed pleadings, the OCPF contribution report, the annual report on file with the Secretary of the Commonwealth, the board's own minutes. A news article describing any of those is secondary. So is a database that summarizes them, until you have checked the underlying document.
Are secondary sources useless?
No, they are leads. A newspaper story tells you a lawsuit exists and roughly when, which is what you need to find the docket. An aggregator tells you a person has lived in three towns, which tells you which Registries to search. The finding is cited to the primary record the lead pointed to.

Related terms

Where this term shows up

Terms that point here: News archive · Findings of fact

← All 537 terms · Scope a brief in sixty seconds →

Hearing this term in a deal right now?

Call before you sign. A straight read on the clause, the number, or the pitch, usually in one conversation.