Glossary · Intelligence & research
Findings of fact
A judge's or board's written determination of what actually happened, made after hearing evidence.
What it means
Findings of fact are the factual conclusions a decision-maker reaches after hearing evidence. In a bench trial the judge writes them, usually alongside rulings of law. Administrative agencies and local boards issue them too: a Massachusetts zoning board must state the reasons for its decision. They are public unless the case is sealed.
Why it matters in a dossier
They are among the strongest sources a researcher can cite. A neutral party heard both sides and put its conclusions in writing. When a dossier says “the court found,” that carries far more weight than “the plaintiff alleged.” We grade sources accordingly, and we check whether the findings were later appealed or reversed before relying on them.
In practice
A subject was sued 3 times. Two cases settled with no findings. The third went to a 4-day bench trial, and the judge’s 22-page decision found that the subject’s company had billed for work it did not perform and awarded $64,000. The dossier quotes that decision directly, cites the docket number, and reports the other 2 cases as resolved without findings. We also confirm no appeal was filed within the deadline, which means the findings stand as the final word.
Straight answers
- How are findings of fact different from allegations in a complaint?
- A complaint is one side's claim, written by its lawyer, before any evidence is tested. Findings of fact come after trial or hearing, when a judge or board has weighed testimony and documents and written down what it concluded. One is an accusation. The other is a decision.
- Do all lawsuits produce findings of fact?
- No, most do not. The large majority of civil cases settle or are dismissed before trial, leaving no findings at all. Findings appear after bench trials, in some administrative hearings, and in local board decisions. Jury verdicts decide the case without a written explanation of the facts.
Related terms
-
Civil docket
The court's running index of every filing, hearing, and order in a civil lawsuit.
-
Source grading (Admiralty code)
Rating each source's reliability (A to F) and each piece of information's credibility (1 to 6).
-
Primary vs. secondary source
The original record of a fact versus someone else's account of it, and why the dossier prefers the former.
-
Confidence levels
Stating how sure the analyst is: high, moderate, or low, and why.