Glossary · Intelligence & research
Corroboration
Confirming a fact through a second independent public source before it is stated as a finding.
What it means
Corroboration is the rule that no single source makes a finding. A fact seen in one record becomes a finding only when a second source, independent of the first, confirms it. A news story is corroborated by the docket it describes. A tip is corroborated by the deed. Until then it is a lead and is labeled as one. Every source is public or licensed; none is obtained by deception.
Why it matters in a dossier
Clients act on dossiers: they walk from deals, reprice offers, and brief attorneys. An uncorroborated error about a Hanover landlord or a Quincy counterparty can cost real money and real reputation. ICS grades every finding by the number and quality of independent sources behind it, and the brief says plainly which items are single-source.
In practice
A reporter’s story says a Taunton developer “walked away from three projects.” The MassCourts search finds one breach-of-contract suit, dismissed. The Registry shows two parcels sold at a loss, roughly 18 percent below purchase price, within 14 months. The finding becomes: one litigated dispute, two distressed sales, no record of a third. That is narrower than the headline, and it is what the client can rely on.
Straight answers
- What counts as an independent source?
- A record that did not derive from the first one. A docket and a news story about that docket are two sources but one origin, so they count once. A docket plus a deed plus a Secretary of the Commonwealth filing that all point the same way are three. ICS counts origins, not copies.
- What happens to a fact that cannot be corroborated?
- It stays in the brief, clearly marked as single-source with a lower confidence grade, or it is dropped if the source itself is weak. It is never upgraded to a finding by repetition. Clients see exactly which items rest on one record so they can decide how much weight to give them.
Related terms
-
Source grading (Admiralty code)
Rating each source's reliability (A to F) and each piece of information's credibility (1 to 6).
-
Confidence levels
Stating how sure the analyst is: high, moderate, or low, and why.
-
Provenance
The documented origin and retrieval trail of each piece of information in a brief.
-
False positive
A record that appears to match the subject of a search but, on inspection, belongs to someone else.
Where this term shows up
In the Insights:
Terms that point here: Adverse media screening · Chronology (timeline analysis) · Disconfirming evidence · Document authentication · Primary vs. secondary source · Due diligence questionnaire · Reference check · Verification