Glossary · Intelligence & research
Provenance
The documented origin and retrieval trail of each piece of information in a brief.
What it means
Provenance is the answer to “where did this come from and how do we know.” For every fact in a brief, it records the source, the date retrieved, the identifier (book and page, docket number, filing ID, archive timestamp), and any intermediate step. A fact without provenance is an assertion. With it, the client, their attorney, or an opposing party can pull the same public record and see the same thing.
Why it matters in a dossier
Dossiers get challenged. A seller’s counsel in Quincy will ask how ICS knows about the lien; a ballot committee will ask where the contribution figure came from. Provenance makes every finding reproducible from public sources. It also keeps the methods honest: a record whose origin cannot be stated is a record that was probably obtained the wrong way, and it does not go in.
In practice
A due-diligence brief on a Taunton warehouse makes 31 factual claims. The appendix lists 31 sources: 12 Registry instruments by book and page, 6 MassCourts docket numbers, 5 Secretary of the Commonwealth filing IDs, 4 municipal documents by meeting date, 3 archived web pages by timestamp, and 1 licensed database query by date. Opposing counsel verifies 9 of them in an afternoon and stops arguing.
Straight answers
- What does provenance look like in an ICS brief?
- A footnote or appendix line for every finding: the source type, the exact identifier, the date pulled, and the confidence grade. For a deed, book and page at the Registry. For a case, the docket number and court. For a web page, the archive URL and timestamp. Anyone with the brief can retrieve the original.
- What if a fact came from a licensed database?
- The brief says so, names the database type, and records the query date. Licensed data is used only where the license permits and only for commercial due diligence, never for employment, credit, insurance, or tenant decisions. Where a public primary record exists, ICS cites that instead and uses the database as the index.
Related terms
-
Chain of custody (for findings)
Documenting where each piece of evidence came from, when, and how it was preserved.
-
Source grading (Admiralty code)
Rating each source's reliability (A to F) and each piece of information's credibility (1 to 6).
-
Document authentication
Verifying that a record is what it claims to be by checking it against the official source that issued it.
-
Corroboration
Confirming a fact through a second independent public source before it is stated as a finding.
Where this term shows up
Terms that point here: Chronology (timeline analysis) · Metadata · Source citation · Web archives (Wayback Machine) · Open-source verification of photos